5164449; New Waterford/Ohio/USA - the city viewtopic.php?f=57&t=22133
5164452; New Waterford Methodist Church/Ohio/USA - the church
will get the exact same forecast and current weather conditions.
METAR station KUCP in New Castle, Pennsylvania is supplying the current conditions only.
It looks like KUCP is still being repaired.
For current conditions, you can use Youngstown as you have on 5164449; New Waterford/Ohio/USA - the city or
you are 16 miles from Beaver Falls County - Beaver Falls, PA (KBVI) or
you can try to use OWM (Open Weather).
The forecast is coming from NWS (or Yr.no).
You can also select OWM for your forecast.
I will be studying KUCP in New Castle to see how long it takes the METAR station to be repaired.
If repairs do not happen soon, I will request an icao change for your 2 locations.
I hope this information helps you.